Theoretical Virtues in Science: Uncovering Reality Through Theory, Cambridge University Press (2018).
- “An impressive achievement” and “a source of new and provocative ideas” (Greg Frost-Arnold for Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews).
- “The book contains a wealth of interesting ideas and arguments” (Rune Nyrup for The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science)
- “makes numerous incisive points” (Darren Bradley for Metascience)
This book offers an in-depth discussion of the features that characterize good scientific theories. Theoretical virtues, as these features are also called, include testability, empirical accuracy, consistency, unifying power, simplicity, and fertility. Theoretical virtues play an important role in theory-choice, as they guide scientists in their decisions to adopt certain theories and not others. Theoretical virtues are also important for what we choose to believe in: only if the theories we possess are good ones can we be confident that our theories’ claims about nature are actually correct. By means of historical cases studies, this book challenges parts of the received view of theoretical virtues and, based on a reconsidered view, advances arguments for the belief that science successfully uncovers reality through theory.
Table of contents:
1. Theoretical virtues, truth, and the argument from simplicity
2. Pessimism, base rates, and the no-virtue-coincidence argument
3. Novel success
4. Theoretical fertility without novel success
5. Ad hoc hypotheses and the argument from coherence
6. Theoretical virtues as confidence boosters and the argument from choice
7. Philosophy of science by historical means
Epilogue: the demarcation problem